Naperville CIty Council accepted an $11.5 million grant towards the purchase of Smart Meters to be installed at residents homes and business, school and churches in the upcoming months. The total project is $22 million, half of which is funded by the federal government, the other half to be funded by tax payers. Additionally, the city has hired a Chicago-based PR firm to handle the PR of the first phase of this project at a potential total price tag of $347,400.
The goal of the council is to help infrastructure improvements and savings that the city and rate-payers will eventually enjoy from the ability to understand their energy usage better. Although there is concern that rate-payers will be seeing significant increases in electric rates as soon as this summer. Rate increases are abundant across the country following Smart Meter installation.
Smart meters are part of the Smart Grid which is a bold step forward in improving energy management of our city. We should applaud our council for having this foresight to set Naperville up for the future use of electric power and intermittent energy sources like wind and solar power.
We should questions the implementation of this technology at this time as multiple flaws in the system have been identified.
They are as follows with more detailed information below:
1) Serious data security holes have been identified leaving the unit susceptible to hacking
2) Serious electrical safety concerns leading to potential for electric burns of residents, appliance burnout, and fire hazards to personal property
3) Inaccurate readings and overcharging the customers.
4) Health concerns regarding the effect of wireless radiation and the loss of freedom to control your exposure in your own home.
Detailed information:
1) serious data security holes have been identified.
AP report released on 3/26/2010 "Many researchers say wireless smart meter technology is being deployed without enough security probing." Senior analyst for InGuardian, Joshua Wright states "all 5 meters studied displayed weakness….."
This means that a hacker could potentially ride their electrical usage on your line and you'd pick up the bill. They could also monitor your energy usage and determine when you are not home. And finally, there is personal data that could be attached to the transmission of the electrical usage data.
2) serious electrical safety concerns
This new technology puts a magnetic (digital) pulse on the AC current that is currently running through your home. There are NO safety studies that ensure the electrical integrity of your home or business stays intact. Magnetic pulse on AC current changes the electrical model and we have no idea what the impact of that will be.
Deregulation in the 70's does not require the appropriate filters to be placed on electrical appliances, thereby opening the door for transient electricity - which is dirty electricity. With the addition of magnet (digital) pulse and no appropriate filters on the wireless smart meters we are leaving ourselves open to faster than usual appliance burnout and potential for electrical burns due to dirty electricity in your home.
An Oak Park resident opted out of the smart meter because of these concerns. She lived in her home for 27 years and it was properly grounded. Because she was surrounded by neighbors who all had smart meters, the dirty electricity surfed on her lines and she experienced substantial electrical burns to her chest. She spoke to city council about her experience.
Note: There are many historical buildings and homes in the Naperville area where the electrical integrity may not be able to handle this new technology yet.
3) Inaccurate readings and over charging of the customers.
An article dated 1/4/2011 reported that Centerpoint Energy is pulling 47,000 wireless smart meters b/c 5,200 wireless meters showed inaccurate readings and were over charging the customers.
Lessons Learned: Canada -- make sure to see the CTV Part 3 report on smart meters for true costs that ratepayers will bear -- consumers there are seeing increases, not decreases in their bills:
4) Heath concerns regarding the effect of wireless radiation and the loss of freedom to control exposure in your own home.
Heath concerns range from unexplained headaches, heart palpation, loss of mental function, excessive fatigue, asthma, depression to more serious concerns such a exasperation of diabetes symptoms, ADD/ADHD, infertility, autoimmune disorders and even cancer. A Swedish study states that 3% of the worlds population is highly sensitive to electromagnetic frequencies and 35% is moderately sensitive. Applying those statics to Naperville means that approximately 4200 - 49,000 residents may experience health issues resulting in lowered quality of life.
Children are especially susceptible and we should pause greatly before installing them on our schools.
Washington Post Article 12/2009 "Technologists already are worried about the security implications of linking nearly all elements of the U.S. power grid to the public Internet. Studies show that the information that the power company may be able to glean include whether a house has
an alarm system and how often it is activated..."
We believe that our city council has had the best of intentions in moving forward with the project. And it is not the intention to stop progress on this project, only to ensure that we proceed with a safe solution that addresses ALL of the concerns above. We feel this is a rushed decision, fueled by the opportunity for grant money and financially based rather than balanced between forward progress and public safety. Wireless smart meters have garnished massive controversy across the world and in our own nation. This technology is unproven, insecure, and unsafe.
We do not want to see Naperville added to the list of communities with public outcry and national media attention because it failed to head the concerns of its citizens.
We do not want to see our city open to potential law suit because these concerns were brought forward and ignored.
We are asking city council to:
1) stall the proposed installation (due to start in March with the 1st phase of the rollout)
2) to provide a hard wired smart meter solution with the appropriate filters to address electrical concerns
3) ensure data security holes be proven and verified safe by a 3rd party consultant prior to installation (which is also accomplished through a hard-wired solution)
Fiber optics or coaxial cable are both reasonable alternatives to collect data from a wired meter vs a wireless meter. Both of which are currently in existence within Naperville. A hard wired smart meter eliminates virtually ALL of these concerns above.
This is an example of the foot steps we like our council to follow in:
Marin County Enacts Moratorium on Smart Meters; "Small Markets" Like Glendale Forging Ahead
Posted By: EditorSmart Meters
The Marin County Board of Supervisors unanimously enacted a one-year moratorium on smart meter installations, citing concerns about the meters' accuracy, the lack of up-to-date safety standards for radiation from a multitude of wireless devices, and the lack of proven savings or consumer benefits from the meters.
City council needs to know that you share these concerns and are not in favor of a full scale implementation until these issues have been addressed.
Cut and paste the above concerns and requests and send to city council and council elects at the following addresses:
The next council meeting is scheduled for 7 pm, March 1 at the Municipal building. We'd like to gather as many as we can who are concerned about this issue to support those who are going to be speaking to city council. Please respond to me if you will be able to attend (lmrooney717@mac.com)
Non-naperville residents are welcomed as the decision in our community will set precedence in yours.
Cut and paste to the following as well:
Inform the local media of your concerns.
Inform your local homeowners association.
Inform your schools parent organization.